Best Kamado Grill: Kamado Joe vs Big Green Egg vs Primo vs Vison vs Weber vs Pit Boss vs Broil King Keg

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

1st
Kamado Joe logo
2nd
Big Green Egg logo
3rd
Primo Oval XL logo

Are you a grill master who has conquered the art of grilling and smoking? Want to kick up your backyard cooking game and explore new techniques? Many experienced grillers swear that kamado grills are the best outdoor residential cooking option. And you can’t beat them for making coal-fired oven pizzas. Here we’ll give you the lowdown on how these grills work and our reviews of the best kamado grill options on the market.

What Is a Kamado Grill?

Kamado grills are charcoal-fueled modern versions of the Chinese and Indian clay, earthenware ovens and urns dating back thousands of years. Most modern kamados are made of thick ceramic shells, but some consist of cast iron and other metals. These materials give kamado grills excellent insulation, allowing them to absorb and radiate heat evenly to hold steady temperatures. They’re excellent at both grilling and smoking because they can maintain very high or very low temperatures. Kamados are perfect for cold climates if you want to cook outdoors all winter.

Best Kamado Grill Winners

We’ve chosen our best kamado style grill rankings based on several factors, including build quality, reputation, features, warranty, pricing and more.

Kamado Joe Classic II Review

#1Kamado Joe Classic II

View on Amazon

The Kamado Joe Classic II wins our top spot as the best kamado grill on the market. Kamado Joe has been manufacturing premium ceramic grills since 2008, and this model is a winner at a competitive price. The Classic II includes features that beat out the Big Green Egg, the industry-leading kamano smoker for decades. Its “Divide and Conquer” cooking system gives you two-zone cooking, with a half rack on two levels so you can get one-half of the grill down lower to the coals. Other standout features include a patented slide-out ash drawer for easy cleaning, a multi-panel firebox, an air assist lift for the cover and a heavy-duty rolling cast iron cart.

Pros

Cons

  • Extremely well built with a thick ceramic, airtight shell
  • Easy DIY assembly
  • Two-level cooking system
  • Slide out ash drawer makes cleaning easier
  • Element-proof top vent
  • Comes with rolling cart, side shelves, diffuser plate, stainless steel grate and grill grippers
  • Owners report excellent customer service
  • Excellent limited lifetime warranty
  • Cart casters could be larger for easier rolling

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • $1,199.00
  • Lifetime limited warranty on ceramic parts
  • 5-year warranty on metal parts
  • Dimensions: 46.5″ W x 48″ H x 28″ D
  • Cooking space: 256 sq. in. (up to 660 sq. in. w/ expanding racks)
  • Weight: 188 lbs.
  • Heat Range: 225°F – 750°F
  • Available in 4 sizes

Big Green Egg Large Cooker Review

#2Big Green Egg

Visit Website

The Big Green Egg wins our number two spot as the best kamado grill. Born in 1974, the Big Green Egg remains the most popular brand of kamado in the world, and devoted fans even call themselves Eggheads. The build quality of premium ceramic materials and grill performance are top-of-the-line with both the Egg and Kamado Joe. And both have excellent limited lifetime warranties. Where the Egg may fall short for some grill masters is fewer features (no handy removable ash tray), the fact that you can’t purchase “the Egg” online, and price. A cart is a must for these grills due to their heavy weight — Kamado Joe comes with a cart, shelving and other handy accessories; the Big Green Egg does not. You have to purchase them separately, which drives the price up considerably.

Pros

Cons

  • Long-standing reputation as the leading kamado
  • Extremely well built with a thick ceramic, airtight shell
  • Easy DIY assembly
  • Tons of unique accessories to choose from
  • Seven sizes available
  • Good customer service
  • Excellent limited lifetime warranty
  • Expensive
  • Can’t purchase online and may not have a dealer near you
  • Must purchase all accessories separately, even a cart
  • Harder to clean — no slide out ash drawer

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • Must contact your local dealer for pricing
  • Lifetime limited warranty on ceramic parts
  • 5-year warranty on metal parts
  • Large model’s cooking space: 262 sq. in. (can expand with 3-grid rack)
  • Large model’s weight: 162 lbs.
  • Also comes in XXL, XL, M, S, Minimax and Mini sizes

Primo Oval XL Review

#3Primo 778 Extra-Large Oval Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill

View on Amazon

The Primo 778 Extra-Large Oval Ceramic Charcoal Smoker Grill rounds out our top three kamado grill winners. This high-end grill is geared toward seasoned grillers and smokers. The Primo 778 has a unique oval shape that makes two-zone cooking a breeze. And you can add a dividable firebox making indirect grilling quick and easy. Primo has years of experience crafting their thick ceramic construction, and owners say this grill is built like a tank. Primo also offers a round grill that is a high performer.

Pros

Cons

  • Extremely well built with a thick ceramic, airtight shell
  • Oval shape makes two-zone cooking easier
  • Allows for direct and indirect cooking
  • Easy DIY assembly
  • Comes with cart and stainless steel side shelves
  • Excellent lifetime warranty
  • Made in the USA
  • More expensive than our top two picks
  • Must purchase dividable firebox and many other accessories separately
  • Harder to clean — no slide out ash drawer
  • Several complaints about poor customer service

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • $1,894.00
  • Lifetime warranty backed by a 20-year guarantee
  • Dimensions: 21″ W x 28″ H x 30″ D
  • Cooking Surface: 400 sq. in. (with rack extensions: up to 680 sq. in.)
  • Weight: 192 lbs.

Other Best Kamado Grill Reviews

We’re not done with our kamado grill comparison reviews yet! Be sure to check out the following popular, and, in some cases, more affordable products.

Broil King Keg 5000 | Pit Boss | Vision Grills | Weber Summit

Broil King Keg 5000 Review

Broil King Keg 5000View on Amazon

Want to wow your fellow tailgaters with a kamado style grilling experience? The Broil King Keg 5000 can do that and more. This charcoal barbecue grill’s major selling point is its portability. Made of lightweight fiberglass encased in powder-coated steel, it’s not as heavy as its ceramic counterparts. And it’s trailer hitch compatible for your party on the go. Even though this grill isn’t ceramic, this bad boy does a superb job of maintaining both super high and low temps like other kamados.

Pros

Cons

  • Attractive price point compared to others
  • Double wall steel insulated body
  • Removable steel ash tray for easier cleaning
  • Removable resin side shelves with integrated tool hooks
  • Durable stand with large wheels for portability
  • Won’t crack if dropped like ceramic kamados
  • Trailer hitch compatible
  • Body isn’t traditional ceramic
  • Assembly isn’t as easy as our top winners
  • Cooking space is smaller than competitors
  • Warranty is only 10 years for body and 2 for parts

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • $854.90 with cart and side shelves
  • 10-year warranty on body
  • 2-year warranty on parts and paint
  • Dimensions: 41″ W x 47″ H x 27.5″ D
  • Cooking space: 280 sq. in. (up to 480 sq. in. w/ expanding racks)
  • Weight: 126 lbs.

Pit Boss Kamado Grill Review

Pit Boss 71240 Kamado BBQ Ceramic Grill CookerView on Amazon

The Pit Boss 71240 Kamado BBQ Ceramic Grill Cooker is another kamado style grill that’s worth consideration. This grill features a heavy ceramic body, dual-tier, stainless steel cooking grids that give you a generous 660 sq. in. of cooking space and a cast iron top tamper that gives you full control over air flow. It comes with a rolling cart and solid bamboo side shelves that fold down for easy storage. All hardware is stainless steel, so rusting shouldn’t be a problem.

Pros

Cons

  • Good value
  • Dual-tier, stainless steel cooking grids
  • Positive user reviews about cooking performance
  • Comes with a rolling cart and side shelves
  • Excellent lifetime limited warranty
  • Some owners report the inner ceramic shell cracks after time
  • Users complain that the bottom slider isn’t tight, so it leaks air
  • Harder to clean — no slide out ash drawer

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • $871.24
  • Lifetime limited warranty on ceramic parts
  • 5-year warranty on metal and cast iron parts
  • Dimensions: 48.5″ W x 53″ H x 30″ D
  • Cooking space: up to 660 sq. in.
  • Weight: 220 lbs.

Vision CF1F1 Pro Kamado Review

Vision CF1F1 Pro KamadoView on Amazon

The Vision CF1F1 Pro Kamado bundle is an excellent value if budget is a priority. This kamado has a heavy-duty ceramic exterior body and fire bowl and a patented ProZone in the bottom, which includes an electric starter port for quick lighting, dedicated smoking and grilling knobs and a handy removable ash drawer. And you get several accessories included in the price: a two-tiered, stainless-steel flip cooking grate, a rolling cart, two side shelves and a heavy duty UV-protected vinyl cover. Overall, users rave about this grill’s value; however, some complain that its temperature control isn’t up to par and it doesn’t maintain low heat settings well.

Pros

Cons

  • Great bundle value
  • Removable steel ash tray for easier cleaning
  • Flip-up stainless steel dual cooking grates
  • Comes with rolling cart, two side shelves, pizza stone and a vinyl kamado grill cover
  • Excellent lifetime limited warranty
  • Several users complain that it’s difficult to control and maintain temps
  • Heavier than most kamado grills
  • Not as airtight as premium grills

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • $948.85
  • Lifetime limited warranty on ceramic parts
  • 5-year warranty on metal parts
  • Dimensions: 52″ W x 47″ H x 28.8″ D
  • Cooking space: 606 sq. in.
  • Weight: 227 lbs.

Weber Summit Charcoal Grill Review

Weber Summit Charcoal GrillView on Amazon

Weber, the popular grill manufacturer, introduced its Summit Charcoal Grill in early 2017, a major upgrade to the Weber Kettle. The design of this kamado-style grill makes it an excellent cooker for both grilling and smoking. It features a two-position charcoal grate that you can raise for improved searing or lower for smoking. And the stainless steel hinged diffuser plate allows for indirect low-temperature cooking. Made of premium-grade U. S. Steel coated with porcelain enamel, the Summit Charcoal grill features a double walled bowl and lid. Air gets trapped between the double walls and acts as an insulator, retaining heat and keeping the temperature consistent. This is a great product, but its price is certainly not budget friendly — especially when you only get a 10-year warranty.

Pros

Cons

  • Weber produces high-quality products
  • Adjustable coal grate for searing or smoking
  • Easy gas ignition system lights the charcoal
  • Removable steel ash tray for easier cleaning
  • Comes with rolling cart
  • Expensive
  • Body isn’t traditional kamado ceramic
  • Cooking space is smaller than others we’ve reviewed here
  • Doesn’t allow for simultaneous tiered cooking
  • Warranty for bowl is only 10 years

Pricing & Tech Specs

  • $1,499.00
  • 10-year warranty on bowl and lid assembly
  • 5-year warranty on metal and plastic parts
  • Dimensions: 39.5″ W x 45.5″ H x 35.8″ D
  • Cooking space: 452 sq. in.
  • Weight: 110 lbs.

Don’t Forget Your Grilling Toys

Our top winner, Kamado Joe, and other kamado grill manufacturers carry a wide variety of accessories to enhance your grilling and smoking experience. And many provide kamado grill recipes in their manuals and on their websites. Check out this video to see what Kamado Joe offers.

Are You an Outdoor Enthusiast?

Do you enjoy other outdoor activities besides grilling? Why not plan a camping excursion? Whether you’re an experienced or novice camper, we’ve got some great info for your next trip. Be sure to check out our camping gear list and reviews of the best tents for camping. Live it up in the great outdoors!

What grilling and smoking tips do you have for wannabe grill masters?

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
An international traveler since she was under 10 years old, Sally loves exploring the world’s mysteries first hand. Her favorite destinations? Greece and the British Virgin Islands. She grew up learning to question, explore, and discover new things and ideas — it’s probably why she went into journalism as a career! She loves what the Internet has brought to research and exploration, but she still hits the ground to travel whenever she gets the chance.

1
Leave a Reply

avatar
newest oldest most voted
Alex
You obviously have not used any of these grills.