Opening Minds and Discovering Life - since 2008
Home > Fun > Take a Tasting Adventure: Best Wine Clubs Reviews

Take a Tasting Adventure: Best Wine Clubs Reviews

How do we keep this site running? This post may contain affiliate links — the cost is the same to you, but we get a referral fee. Compensation does not affect rankings. Thanks!

1st
Gold Medal Wine Club logo
2nd
Plonk Wine Club logo
3rd
Tasting Room logo

Are you a wanna-be wine connoisseur? Or just tired of the limited selection at your local market? Wine is one of life’s great pleasures—and mysteries. How do winemakers transform grapes into such superb sipping sensations? If you’re a wine lover and want to explore beyond the normal retail offerings, you should consider joining a wine club. You might be amazed at the variety of tastes, aromas, grape types, growing regions, etc. that you can explore with a subscription to one the best wine clubs—not to mention the savings on elegant, premium wines you’ll enjoy as a wine club member. Read our best wine club reviews to see our top picks.

Can I Receive Wine Shipments Where I Live?

Before moving on to our wine club reviews and rankings, a word about shipping wine and other alcoholic beverages. There are a handful of states whose laws are strict about shipping alcohol. If you live in one of these states you’re likely aware of the differing alcohol laws, but if you’re gifting a wine subscription for a friend or loved one take note. It can be a bit confusing. But that’s why we’re here!

FedEx doesn’t ship alcohol to certain states, but other shippers may. It depends on each wine club’s set-up with its shippers. So, in our reviews below we’ll tell you if a wine club doesn’t ship to your desired location. One more important item—no matter, where you live, you must have someone at home who’s over 21 to sign for your wine deliveries. Now, on to our wine club of the month reviews!

Best Wine Clubs of the Month

There are dozens of extraordinary—and we mean, truly excellent—wine clubs out there, folks. The competition is fierce, and it hasn’t been easy to choose (and rank) the best wine clubs online! We based our picks on a number of factors including wine quality, regional variety, variety of subscription, the club’s “fun factor,” pricing, shipping options and more.

Gold Medal Wine Club Review

#1

View Wine Club

Gold Medal Wine Club, our winner for best monthly wine club, delivers a full-flavored experience—much more than just the wine itself. With six different subscriptions at affordable pricing, Gold Medal features consistently excellent wines (many award-winning) from boutique wineries in California and around the world. Every wine shipment includes a full-color publication about each region, winery, winemaker as well as other fascinating facts. And foodies, take note! With the international subscription, you can even order their Gourmet Adventure Package that includes featured foods from the winery’s region. If you love the history and geography of wine as much as the wine itself, this is the wine membership for you! Shipping not available in Utah.

Pros

Cons

  • Competitive pricing
  • Huge variety of subscription options
  • Members earn rewards discounts up to 40% off toward online store purchases
  • Features award-winning wines 
  • Excellent customer service with live chat
  • Satisfaction guarantee (but it’s unclear if they offer refunds or replacement bottles)
  • Extensive online resources about wine, regions, store, etc.
  • Member discounts on wine club gift options
  • No contract/cancel anytime
  • Charges shipping fees (varies by location and number of bottles)
  • No mention of environmental practices

Pricing

Gold Medal Wine Club’s Gold, Platinum and Diamond pricing tiers are based on wine ratings.

Gold Series (all California wines)

  • $37 per month starting price for 2 bottles (also 4-bottle/month option)
  • Choose from 3 options: mix, red only or white only
  • Available monthly, every other month or quarterly

Platinum Series (all California wines)

  • $89 per month starting price for 2 bottles (also 4-bottle/month option)
  • Choose from 2 options: mostly reds or all reds
  • Available monthly, every other month or quarterly

Diamond Series (highest quality from California and around the world)

  • $179 quarterly starting price for 2 bottles
  • Choose from 2 options: mostly reds or all reds
  • Available quarterly only

Garagiste (sourced from small-lot winemakers, mostly in California)

  • $75 per month starting price for 2 bottles (also 4-bottle/month option)
  • Choose from 2 options: mostly reds or all reds
  • Available monthly, every other month or quarterly

Pinot Noir

  • $74 per month starting price for 2 bottles (also 4-bottle/month option)
  • Available monthly, every other month or quarterly

International

  • $75 per month starting price for 3 bottles (includes 2 reds and 1 white)
  • Available quarterly only

Coupon

Get a Free Bottle of Wine from Gold Medal Wine Club with the purchase of a 3 month or more subscription. Click here to take advantage of this offer!

Plonk Wine Club Review

#2

View Wine Club

Plonk Wine Club comes in a close second in our rankings. Plonk offers a pretty wide variety of wine club subscriptions. You can choose one of their Curated Wine Clubs (mixed, white only or red only), and they also offer Grape Variety Wine Clubs, including Cabernet, Pinot Noir or Sauvignon Blanc. All of their wines include international selections from lesser known vineyards that grow organically. They do the choosing for you, and based on customer reviews; they do a great job at finding “hidden gems.” Plonk Wine Club also gives you fun recipe pairing ideas and tasting notes with every shipment. Shipping not available in Alaska, Arkansas, Hawaii, and Utah. 

Pros

Cons

  • Free shipping
  • Wide variety of subscription options
  • 100% money back guarantee
  • Offers up to 16% discounts for re-ordering
  • Environmental focus with organic growers, etc.
  • Good customer service
  • Top-rated wine selections from around the world
  • Wine club gift subscriptions available
  • Cancel anytime
  • A bit pricier than our other wine club reviews
  • No live chat
  • Website resources not as extensive as our #1 pick

Pricing

Plonk Curated Wine Clubs

  • Choose from 3 plans: Mixed, Red or White
  • $49.99 per month for 2 bottles
  • $89.99 per month for 4 bottles
  • $249.99 per month for 12 bottles

Plonk Grape Variety Wine Clubs

  • Choose from 3 plans: Cabernet, Pinot Noir or Sauvignon Blanc
  • $64.99 per month for 2 bottles

Coupon

Until May 15th, 2017, Get $10 Off All Orders with Code MOM2017 via this link!

Tasting Room by Lot18 Review

#3

View Wine Club

Tasting Room, our number three pick in our best wine subscription reviews, offers a fun, creative twist to the typical monthly wine subscription. You start off with their $9.95 tasting kit, which includes 6 mini bottles of various wines, and rate them to your personal taste. Then they send you a personalized wine profile including details about your individual palate. A month later, you’ll receive your first shipment of 12 international wines hand-picked for you based on your profile. You continue to rate each wine as you pour your way through them, and they adjust their next shipment based on your preferences (shipments are every two months, but you can adjust your desired length of time between each delivery). The set cost at $149 per case is an excellent value for the high-quality wines they select. Tasting Room is a fun way to delve into wine tasting for novices, but if you’re already a connoisseur, you probably want to go with another club. Shipping not available in Alaska, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Utah, and Vermont.

Pros

Cons

  • Excellent price per bottle
  • Option to set your own shipping schedule
  • Can cancel anytime
  • Offers credit or replacement bottle if you dislike a wine
  • Personalized high-quality wine selections
  • Good customer service reputation
  • Discounts on select wines at online store
  • Gifting options
  • Only option is 12 bottle shipment
  • Hefty shipping fee
  • No environmental practices
  • No live chat

Pricing

  • $9.95 starter tasting kit
  • $149 for 12 bottles (every 2 months but adjustable)
  • $19.95 shipping per case

Coupon

There are no tasting room coupons at this time.

Other Best Wine of the Month Club Reviews

Although the following wine subscriptions didn’t make it into our top three rankings, they’re still among the best wine clubs around! In our opinion, you really can’t go wrong with any of our wine club recommendations.

International Wine of the Month Club | The Original Wine of the Month Club | Winc

International Wine of the Month Club Review

International Wine of the Month Club logoView Wine Club

International Wine of the Month Club arguably has the most stringent vetting process to find the best tasting international wines. Their panel of 40 wine enthusiasts, ranging from novices to expert sommeliers and well-seasoned importers, rate hundreds of estate bottled wines from boutique winemakers around the world. You know you’re getting high quality and an excellent variety for a lot less than you’d pay at each winery. Unfortunately, International Wine of the Month Club only offers three levels of wine subscription boxes—and you only receive two bottles per month with whichever level you choose (although you can subscribe to multiple club levels at the same time). Shipment not available in Alaska, Hawaii, and Utah.

Pros

Cons

  • Competitive pricing, even for its “Collection Series”
  • Long history of high-quality wines (since 1994)
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (they’ll refund or replace a bottle you didn’t like)
  • Environmentally friendly business practices
  • Excellent online resources, including FAQ, blog, region guide and more
  • Good customer service with live chat
  • Other club offerings: beer, cheese, chocolate, etc.
  • Steep shipping charge of $13 per month
  • Subscriptions only ship 2 bottles per month
  • Not as much variety in monthly offerings as other clubs

Pricing

International Wine of the Month Club ships 2 bottles of wine per month with each pricing level.

Premier Series

  • $35.95 per month plus $13 shipping
  • Choice of mixed, 2 reds or 2 whites

Masters Series

  • $52.95 per month plus $13 shipping
  • Choice of mixed or 2 reds

Collectors Series

  • $72.95 per month plus $13 shipping
  • Choice of mixed or 2 reds

The Original Wine of the Month Club Review

The Original Wine of the Month Club logoView Wine Club

As its name implies, The Original Wine of the Month Club was the first ever mail order wine club, dating back to 1972—and they’re still going strong today despite a ton of tough competition. A good choice for beginner and experienced wine drinkers, the Original Wine of the Month Club isn’t quite as adventurous as some of our other best wine club picks (you can find all their offerings elsewhere). But they’ve remained a top contender in this category for decades with consistently palate-pleasing choices. And their prices are hard to beat! Shipping not available in Arkansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Utah or Vermont.

Pros

Cons

  • Most affordable compared to our other reviews
  • Good variety of subscription choices
  • No contract required/cancel anytime
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (replacement or reimbursement for wine you dislike)
  • Excellent website resources, including blog, podcasts, videos, articles and more
  • Can choose delivery every month, every other month or quarterly (except with Cellar Series)
  • Excellent customer service with live chat
  • Shipping charges apply (starts at $9.75/month but varies on location and number of bottles)
  • Wine selections not quite as adventurous as some other clubs
  • No environmental practices mentioned on website

Pricing

Two Bottle Clubs

With each of the following clubs you get 2 bottles and can choose monthly, every other month or quarterly shipments. The prices below only reflect the monthly subscription cost.

  • Classic Series: $23.96 per month (choice of mix, red only or white only)
  • California Series: $28.96 per month (red only)
  • Vintners Series: $33.96 per month (mix, red only or white only)
  • Limited Series: $44.96 per month (mix, red only or white only)

Six Bottle Club

This club only ships every other month.

  • Cellar Series: $71.88 per shipment (mix, red only or white only)

Winc Review

Club W logoView Wine Club

Winc, formerly known as Club W, differs from most other wine clubs in that they contract directly with vineyards, farmers, and winemakers to create their own wines. The plus with this model is you get to try wines that are totally unique to the club. The only downside? If you find a wine through Winc you can’t live without, you may be out of luck—Winc cycles through their offerings and doesn’t always keep past wines available for reordering. Still, Winc is one of the more affordable wine clubs, and they consistently deliver excellent and adventurous wine tasting. Shipping not available in Alaska, Alabama, Arkansas, Delaware, Hawaii, Kentucky, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Utah.

Pros

Cons

  • Extremely affordable compared to other clubs
  • Wines totally unique to the club
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (they’ll refund or replace a bottle you didn’t like)
  • Can cancel anytime
  • Offers wine club gift subscriptions
  • Good customer service with live chat
  • Committed to sustainable business practices
  • Shipping charge $6 per month
  • Only one subscription option
  • Don’t always carry past offerings
  • No discounts on reordering

Pricing

  • $39 for 3 bottles per month
  • $6 shipping

Are You a Wine Newbie? Wine 101

If you’re new to wine or just have never taken the time to learn about different types of wines, check this video by allrecipes.com that gives you a quick tutorial on wine varieties and regions around the world where certain grape types thrive.

Why Join a Wine Club?

Joining a wine club gives you access to estate wines and wine from lesser-known boutique wineries from around the world that you’d have a difficult (or impossible) time finding on your own—and they’re hand-picked by experts. Not only that, you get some great deals on high-quality wines, saving you on average 40% off retail pricing. There are so many wine clubs online—and many that are great choices for beginner and sophisticated wine drinkers alike. Happy sipping!

Which wine of the month clubs are you considering?

An international traveler since she was under 10 years old, Sally loves exploring the world’s mysteries first hand. Her favorite destinations? Greece and the British Virgin Islands. She grew up learning to question, explore, and discover new things and ideas — it’s probably why she went into journalism as a career! She loves what the Internet has brought to research and exploration, but she still hits the ground to travel whenever she gets the chance.

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Take a Tasting Adventure: Best Wine Clubs Reviews"

avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Lush Lindsey
Lush Lindsey

Does anyone have any personal recommendations with these wine subscription services? I am currently testing out all the various meal prep boxes to see which I like best (best tasting, less packaging, most meal options etc) but didn’t know if there was a big difference between these clubs other than the pricing and selection? Thanks!

wpDiscuz

Send this to a friend