Best Beer of the Month Club: Which Hops Shop Comes Out on Top?

How do we keep this site running? This post may contain affiliate links — the cost is the same to you, but we get a referral fee. Compensation does not affect rankings. Thanks!

1st
The Rare Beer Club logo small
2nd
The U.S. and International Variety Beer Club logo small
3rd
The Original Craft Beer Club logo small

Are you a beer enthusiast who’s tired of your same old local store offerings? Fortunately, microbrewing is a booming — and very trendy — business these days. New breweries are popping up all over the U.S. and the world every day. Thanks to a batch of online beer subscriptions, you can sample some of the best new beers before they hit the market and maybe even a few that are not available in your local bottle shop. Check out our best beer of the month club reviews to see which monthly beer subscription can satisfy your thirst for new brews.

Best Beer of the Month Club Winners

We’ve chosen our winners based on several factors including the quality and variety of beer delivered to your door, informational offerings via blogs or newsletters, the variety of subscription options, cost and more.

The Rare Beer Club Review

#1

Visit Website

The Rare Beer Club wins our top spot as the best beer of the month club. Brought to you by the world-renowned beer critic, Michael Jackson and his taste-testing panel of experts, this club is all about rare beer finds from craft breweries around the world. You’ll be introduced to exclusive beers before they make it to the U.S. market, brews developed solely for the Rare Beer Club, and Imperial and Extreme beers, which are heartier versions of existing styles (more malt, more hops, and much higher ABVs). Types of selections include hard ales, sour ales, IPAs, stouts, lagers and more. They offer a wide variety of subscription/gift options, with a minimum of two shipments to get started.

Pros

Cons

  • You can customize or skip each monthly beer box
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (replace or refund)
  • Wide variety of subscription options (most aren’t ongoing)
  • Monthly newsletter with tasting notes, beer profiles, brewery histories, and suggested food pairings
  • Extensive online resources about craft brews
  • No contract/cancel anytime
  • Expensive subscriptions
  • Hefty shipping fees per delivery

Pricing

All of the Rare Beer Club selections come in 750 ml bottles, and most are cork finished and wire caged. You receive two separate beer selections in every shipment. The four bottle option includes two of each selection, and the six bottle option has three of each. See all plans.

Number of Bottles Per Shipment2 Bottles4 Bottles6 Bottles
Price Per Shipment$35.95$53.95$70.95
Shipping Fees Per Shipment$14$16$19

The U.S. and International Variety Beer Club Review

#2

Visit Website

Our number two pick for the best beer of the month club is the U.S. and International Variety Beer Club, from the same corporation that runs the Rare Beer of the Month Club. This company and its expert tasting panel know what they’re doing when it comes to fine brews. With this club, you’ll receive hand-crafted beers from both U.S. craft microbreweries and International breweries — 12, 12 oz. bottles from two different U.S. microbreweries and two different microbreweries from overseas (three bottles each). This beer club is the company’s most popular package for the variety of beers you receive and less expensive subscription fees compared to their Rare Beer Club pricing.

Pros

Cons

  • Very affordable pricing
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (replace or refund)
  • Wide variety of subscription options (most aren’t ongoing)
  • Monthly newsletter with tasting notes, beer profiles, brewery histories, and suggested food pairings
  • Extensive online resources about craft brews
  • No contract/cancel anytime
  • Hefty shipping fees per delivery
  • Not as many premier-quality, rare beer finds as our number one pick
  • Customization and skipping months is not an option

Pricing

U.S. and International Variety Beer Club sends you four different beer styles, three of each style.

Enjoying This Article? Read our Cigar Club Reviews

The Original Craft Beer Club Review

#3

Visit Website

The Original Craft Beer Club takes our number three spot as the best craft beer subscription service. Like our top two clubs, the Craft Beer Club has a panel of experts that sample hundreds of beers per year to give you the highest quality craft brews. They select a wide variety of beers, including ales, lagers, stouts and porters, from independent American brewers that produce small batches. The downsides to this craft beer of the month club are fewer subscription options and ongoing charges to your credit card, so you have to remember to cancel if you no longer want their beer boxes. But the Original Craft Beer Club offers competitive pricing and free shipping.

Pros

Cons

  • Average pricing and free shipping
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (replace or refund)
  • Monthly newsletter with info about each beer
  • Free annual subscription to Beer Connoisseur E-Magazine
  • No contract/cancel anytime
  • Not as many subscription options as other clubs, and all are ongoing
  • Customization is limited
  • May ship cans occasionally

Pricing

The Original Craft Beer of the Month Club offers monthly, every other month or quarterly shipping options with automatic renewal. Shipping is free.

  • $42 per shipment for 12 beers (4 styles, 3 of each)
  • $80 per shipment for 24 beers (4 styles, 6 of each)
  • See all plans

Other Beer of the Month Club Reviews

Below are our reviews of a few more popular monthly beer clubs. They didn’t make it into our top three but are worth considering.

Amazing Clubs |Clubs Galore  | Clubs of America

Amazing Clubs Beer of the Month Club Review

Amazing Clubs Beer of the Month Club logo

Visit Website

Amazing Clubs offers 40 different subscription clubs, everything from beer to teddy bears. And it seems that they’ve spread themselves too thin to offer the highest quality and variety of products, at least when it comes to their monthly beer box. You do get 12 quality beers (ales, lagers, stouts, porters, etc.) from award-winning breweries around the U.S. with every shipment, but they’re not unique or hard-to-find brews. And beer enthusiasts will likely find the lack of an informative newsletter about each beer and minimal website resources disappointing.

Pros

Cons

  • Competitive pricing
  • Free shipping
  • Can cancel anytime if you opt for ongoing pay per shipment
  • Good customer service hours, via live chat and phone
  • Quality and variety not up to par with many other clubs and no international beers
  • Their customer “guarantee” doesn’t promise replacements or refunds
  • Fewer subscription options than some competitors
  • No customization available
  • Some consumer complaints about unhelpful customer service agents

Pricing

  • $39.95 per shipment ongoing until you cancel (delivery every month or every other month)
  • $116.85 for 3 Month Club (delivered every month or every other month; $38.95 per shipment)
  • $155.80 for Seasonal (4 Month) Club (delivered every 3rd month; $38.95 per shipment)
  • $227.70 for 6 Month Club (delivered every month or every other month; $37.95 per shipment)
  • $443.40 for 12 Month Club (delivered every month or every other month; $36.95 per shipment)
  • See all plans

Clubs Galore Beer of the Month Club Review

Clubs Galore Beer of the Month Club logo

Visit Website

Clubs Galore seems to be another mega-specialty box subscription company that doesn’t specialize in beer. Their beer subscription box is on the expensive side, but they offer more variety and fun beer facts than Amazing Clubs. And you get four different selections (three of each) every shipment including hard-to-find, award-winning beers from U.S. and International breweries. Like many other clubs, they provide a variety of beer types and an informational newsletter about each beer you’re receiving. Clubs Galore is a decent choice if you don’t mind paying more than similar clubs.

Pros

Cons

  • Free shipping
  • Good variety of domestic and international brews
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee (30-day refund policy)
  • Beer Blog Newsletter provides tasting notes and profiles about the beer in each shipment
  • Can customize with other membership clubs (bacon, bourbon, etc.)
  • Good customer service
  • Pricey subscriptions at $49.99/month
  • Minimum purchase requires three months of boxes (but you can cancel and request a refund for boxes not yet delivered)
  • Only one beer box type offered and can’t customize beers

Pricing

Clubs Galore gives you the option of purchasing anywhere from 3-12 months of boxes with delivery monthly, every other month or every third month.

  • $49.99 per shipment for 12 beers (4 styles; 3 of each kind)

Clubs of America Beer of the Month Club Review

Clubs of America Beer of the Month Club logo

Visit Website

Clubs of America Beer of the Month Club has delivered more than 3 million shipments since its founding in 1994 — a testament to the reputation and popularity of this club. Every beer subscription box includes only the finest, award-winning beers from small American microbreweries. They seem to be a bit heavy on ales, but they also deliver pilsners, IPAs, stouts and lagers. With a money-back guarantee and free shipping, this Club can be a great option, unless you want international beers or if you mind the occasional can instead of a bottle.

Pros

Cons

  • Average pricing and free shipping
  • Good variety and quality of domestic beers
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Beer Expeditions newsletter with details of each beer and tasting notes
  • Option to pay in full or monthly (can cancel anytime)
  • Can customize with other membership clubs
  • No international beers
  • Only one box type offered and no customization
  • May ship cans occasionally

Pricing

Clubs of America offers one to 12 months options with a $25 discount if you opt for the 12-month subscription. You can choose delivery every month, every other month or every third month.

Enjoying This Article? Read our Wine Club Reviews

What’s Up With the Latest Beer Trends?

Check out this video which features a Men’s Journal expert editor who shares some trends in the U.S. craft beer world.

Guzzle or Gift It?

These beer of the month subscriptions are a great way to indulge in your own brew interests, but they also make a perfect gift for fellow beer enthusiasts. Any of the beer boxes we’ve reviewed here would make great gifts, especially since these libations could keep on giving for a few months beyond the initial celebrations! And if you’ve ever had the inkling to brew your own beer, be sure to check out our home brewing kit comparison article.

What do you want out of a beer club monthly delivery?

An international traveler since she was under 10 years old, Sally loves exploring the world’s mysteries first hand. Her favorite destinations? Greece and the British Virgin Islands. She grew up learning to question, explore, and discover new things and ideas — it’s probably why she went into journalism as a career! She loves what the Internet has brought to research and exploration, but she still hits the ground to travel whenever she gets the chance.

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Best Beer of the Month Club: Which Hops Shop Comes Out on Top?"

avatar
SKC15
SKC15

So tough to decide, going to get my husband one of these for his birthday next month, he’s a big fan of craft beer though so think that’s the best pick for him.

wpDiscuz

Send this to a friend