Best Cigar of the Month Club: Who’s the Puff Daddy?

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

1st
Premium Cigar of the Month Club logo
2nd
Cigars International Club logo
3rd

Are you, or is someone you know, a cigar aficionado? Or are you just starting to delve into the flavorful, aromatic world of cigars? From cigar manufacturers based in Havana, Cuba and the Dominican Republic to Jamaica and the good old USA, there are so many truly excellent cigars and tobacco blends to discover.

Why not try one of many cigar of the month clubs available online? For a small cost, you can receive several premium cigars every month that are selected by cigar experts. We’ve reviewed the top monthly cigar subscription services to give you all the information you need if you’re considering a cigar of the month club.

Best Cigar Clubs Of The Month

How did we select the best cigar subscription? We based our top picks on many factors including:

  • Cigar quality
  • Variety of subscriptions
  • Delivery options
  • Educational resources
  • Pricing
  • Whether clubs ship their cigars in humidified packaging. Humidification is important because cigars can dry out quickly and they lose their flavor and bouquet.

The Premium Cigar Of The Month Club Review

#1

View Website

The Premium Cigar of the Month Club wins our top spot for the best cigar club of the month. In addition to attractive monthly pricing, a lot of flexibility in subscription options, and a 100% satisfaction guarantee, we love their selection process.

The Premium Cigar of the Month Club has a panel of nine professional tobacconists, who smoke more than 200 cigars each month. And they choose less than 5% of these cigars for club selections. The result? You get five premium, flavorful, well-crafted cigars in every shipment.

They search the globe for top cigars—from limited production, boutique manufacturers to super-premium brands that you’d end up paying much more for on your own.

Pros

Cons

  • Competitive pricing
  • Huge variety of subscription options
  • Features award-winning, high-quality cigars
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Fun newsletter about each cigar’s origin, tobacco blend, manufacturer, etc. in each shipment
  • Cigars shipped in portable humidification device
  • No contract/cancel anytime
  • Excellent customer service with live chat
  • Charges $5 shipping fee
  • No member discounts for online purchases

Pricing

You can choose from 2 to 12 months or an open-ended monthly account, which you can call and cancel anytime. Design your own “club” by selecting monthly, every other month or quarterly deliveries, or even choose specific months.

  • $24.95 per shipment
  • $5.00 shipping with each delivery

Coupon

Cigar of the Month Club Holiday Offer, valid until January 2nd: Get $10 off any 4 shipment order with code SAVE10; Get $25 off any prepaid order of 6 shipments or more with code SAVE15; Get $25 off any prepaid order of 12 shipments or more with SAVE25. Just use this link to take advantage of this offer.

Cigars International Club Review

#2

View Website

Cigars International comes in second place in our best cigar monthly subscription reviews for their affordable pricing, wide variety of international cigar selections and 100% satisfaction guarantee. While they don’t offer as much flexibility in subscriptions and delivery options as our top pick, they do give you a choice of a month-to-month plan or prepaying for anywhere from 2 to 12 months.

The good news? You can cancel anytime with all subscription plans before shipment. What kept Cigars International from our top spot? They don’t ship in humidified packaging to preserve all the flavor and craftsmanship of the cigars. And they don’t list current or past cigar club selections. However, they claim that all club selection cigars are hand-rolled and premium to super-premium quality.

Cigars International gets high marks from consumers for the quality and reliability of their products, and their large inventory. Like a cigar from the club? You can stock up with a separate order on their website.

Pros

Cons

  • More affordable pricing
  • Free shipping
  • Member discounts
  • All cigars are hand-rolled, premium quality
  • Good variety of subscription options
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Informative newsletter with each shipment
  • Can cancel anytime
  • Good customer service reputation
  • Great site for purchasing your favorite cigars individually or in bulk outside of the club
  • No humidified shipping
  • No live chat
  • Not as many website resources as other clubs

Pricing

With each pricing plan you incur a $5.00 set-up/shipping fee, but shipping is free after the first month.

  • $19.95 per month (4 cigars)
  • $29.95 per month (8 cigars; 2 each of 4 brands)
  • Choose month-to-month or prepaid 2-12 month subscription

Cigar.com Cigar Of The Month Club Review

#3

View Website

Cigar.com rounds out our top three best monthly cigar club. Cigar.com knows their cigars. They’re a leading online cigar store, with thousands of cigars available for purchase from around the world. Their Cigar of the Month Club is a customer favorite for both gifting and personal pleasure.

Every month you’ll enjoy five selections, but they don’t just focus on hard-to-find premium cigars. Each shipment includes one “featured” cigar (a brand new blend or well-known super premium) and two cigars recommended by their experts.

They also include two “everyday smokes,” which are affordable but dependable cigars you can enjoy every day.  If you’re looking for limited or rare blends, this probably isn’t the club for you. But Cigar.com is an excellent choice if you’re just beginning to dabble in cigars.

Pros

Cons

  • Flexible subscription options
  • Good variety of quality cigars
  • Offers 10% discounts for their online products
  • Full refund for returns
  • Newsletter detailing every cigar in your monthly shipment
  • Humidified shipping
  • Cancel anytime
  • Excellent website resources, including industry leading online forum, videos, articles and more
  • Good customer service
  • A bit pricier than our other cigar club reviews
  • Shipping fees
  • No live chat

Pricing

Cigars.com Cigar of the Month Club offers an excellent First Month Bonus: three free cigars and a free cutter. Club members also enjoy 10% discounts on most of their products.

  • $29.95 per month for 5 cigars (plus $3.95 shipping)
  • $53.95 per month for 10 cigars (plus $3.95 shipping)
  • Choice of month-to-month plan or prepaid 2-12 months

Other Best Cigar Of The Month Club Reviews

The following cigar clubs just missed our top three rankings, but we recommend you take a look at them if you’re considering joining a cigar club.

JR Cigar ClubThompson Cigar of the Month Club

JR Cigar Club Review

JR Cigar Club logoView Website

What is JR Cigar’s main selling point? It’s the world’s largest cigar store, carrying thousands of brands from cheaper machine pressed to premium hand-rolled cigars. JR Cigar recently launched a cigar of the month club that selects five premium cigars every month delivered right to your door.

If you don’t know much about cigars, JR Cigar could be a great place to start. Their online resources alone are a fun and extremely informative way to discover the cigar world. They offer past club choices, a blog, and even JR University to help you grow your knowledge.

If you’re already a cigar aficionado, however, you probably won’t find the unique selections you can get with some other monthly cigar clubs.

Pros

Cons

  • Competitive pricing
  • Free shipping
  • Premium cigars selected from thousands of their online offerings
  • Excellent website learning tools, including blog, videos, articles
  • Can cancel anytime
  • Not as many subscription and delivery options as other plans
  • No member discounts
  • No satisfaction guarantee and no return policy for monthly club sales
  • Doesn’t ship in humidified packaging
  • You don’t get an informational newsletter with each shipment

Pricing

  • $24.95 per month (free shipping)
  • Choice of ongoing monthly shipments or prepaid 6 or 12 month subscriptions

Thompson Cigar of the Month Club Review

Thompson Cigar logoView Website

Thompson Cigar, founded in Key West, Florida in 1915,  is the oldest mail order cigar company in the country. Thompson’s private label cigars and monthly club selections offer some of the finest cigars at a fraction of what comparable national brand products would cost.

Thompson, like JR Cigar, is a large-scale online store that offers cigars for purchase in addition to their cigar of the month club. Thompson Cigar, unlike JR Cigar, offers more subscription options and a 100% satisfaction guarantee. But their slightly higher monthly pricing keeps them out of our top three picks.

Pros

Cons

  • Free shipping with all deliveries
  • Good variety of subscription choices
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Informational newsletter included in every shipment
  • Good website resources
  • No contract required/cancel anytime
  • Monthly pricing a bit higher than other top clubs
  • Cigar selections not as unique as some other clubs
  • No humidification shipping

Pricing

You get a free cigar cutter with your first shipment and can cancel your subscription anytime before Thompson Cigar processes your next shipment.

  • $29.95 per month for 5 cigars (month-to-month or prepaid 3, 6, 9 or 12 months)
  • $53.95 per month for 10 cigars (only available as a month-to-month cigar subscription)

How Do You Cut A Cigar?

In a recent online poll conducted by Cigar Aficionado, 81% of readers reported using a double blade guillotine. If you’re a cigar newbie, you may not know that there are several methods you can use to cut your cigars. Check out this video by Cigar.com that explains the differences.

Why Join A Monthly Cigar Club?

Whether you’re a cigar freshman or a seasoned cigar lover, membership in a cigar of the month club is an excellent way to explore premium cigars that you may not find on your own. And you end up paying much less for high-quality cigars than you would be going the retail route. It’s a surprising treat every month and a fun gifting option for that cigar lover in your life. Looking for more fun in the mail on a regular basis?

Now that you’ve read about the best cigar website, be sure to check out our beer and wine club reviews too!

Do you have any cigar of the month clubs to recommend?

An international traveler since she was under 10 years old, Sally loves exploring the world’s mysteries first hand. Her favorite destinations? Greece and the British Virgin Islands. She grew up learning to question, explore, and discover new things and ideas — it’s probably why she went into journalism as a career! She loves what the Internet has brought to research and exploration, but she still hits the ground to travel whenever she gets the chance.

3
Leave a Reply

2 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
CigarGuy
Great list of clubs! I’ve been shopping around for a good club to join. Trying to read as many reviews as possible before I take the plunge. Found another site with pretty in depth reviews & looks like your ratings are pretty close to theirs for the same clubs. I’ve been leaning towards the Premium Cigar of the Month Club. I think I’ll bite the bullet and join!
Sadie CorneliusAdmin
Great glad to hear we could help and let us know how it works out with the stogies!
Sidney L
Who knew there were so many cigar of the month clubs!? I am looking into client gifts and in the past these “club” type of gifts have been a great option in the past because it’s the gift that keeps on giving. One client in particular is a big cigar aficionado so am excited to check these out and give as a gift this year!